Options
Research Article

Test paper 10th June

Author
  • Andy Author

This article is a preprint and is currently undergoing peer review by UCL Open: Environment.

Abstract

This is an accepted article with a DOI pre-assigned that is not yet published.

Abstract text etc ...

Keywords: keyword 1

Preprint Under Review
License
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0

 Open peer review from Lizzy Seal

Review

My review and detailed comments ...



Would you be willing to review a revised version of this paper?
Yes

Please evaluate the paper's empirical contribution from 1 (no clear empirical contribution) to 5 (highly impactful empirical contribution)
1

Please evaluate the paper's theoretical contribution, ranging from 1 (no clear theoretical contribution) to 5 (highly impactful theoretical contribution)
1

Please evaluate the paper's coherence and argumentation, ranging from 1 (very weak argumentation) to 5 (exceptionally clear, coherent argumentation)
1

Please evaluate the paper's methodological soundness, ranging from 1 (severe concerns with the methodology) to 5 (exemplary methodological practices)
1

Note:
This review refers to round 1 of peer review.